like asians being more inclined to studying.
This is wrong on so many levels.
Genes can not influence cognitive/memetic systems at all, they can only create them. They can create 'embedded' routines, what we call instinct.
Take, for example, a species of wasp in Richar Dawkins' book The Selfish Gene. The wasp will injure (but not kill) a caterpiller or other large insect, then dig a pit, then check the pit to make sure it's empty, then place the victim in, then lay its eggs, and then bury them all.
A study was conducted where the researchers would let the wasp get to the point of dragging the victim into the pit. But, they would pull the victim a few inches away just as the wasp was finished checking the pit. The wasp would go drag the victim back, and do something extraordinary. It would check the pit again. If the victim was dragged back again, the wasp would repeat this process. They tried this over 20 times, and the wasp never 'caught on'. In effect, its genetically programmed instincts were not 'smart'.
So, returning to your point, if Asians are predisposed to studying then that means if I were to take an Asian, and place him/her near a textbook they would have an incredible urge to start reading the book. Infact, if your conjecture were true, I could place a book and a million dollars side by side, if studying in Asians was a genetic trait, they would have no choice but to be drawn to the book because money is of no genetic interest. But this doesn't happen, because being predisposed to study is a memetic trait. Perhaps Asians do have memeplexes which do predispose them to study, indeed, I would support this argument.
Here's another problem with the racial-advantages argument. Books, money, all these things are human creations only a few thousand years old. Genes take millions of years to preform their magic. Moreover, they only prosper (in relation to any opposing genes in the pool) if they aid the host. Do scientists have a better chance of reproducing than a regular Joe? No. Indeed, in a society such as ours being a scientist may even hinder reproduction :)
I think you're making the same mistake many racists, such as the Ku Klux Klan, make. You are attributing memetic, in this case, sociological differences in races to innate characteristics. Jews have been in banking because, as a society, they have decided to move in that direction. When a large group decides to do something like that, it becomes inevitible that they will succeed.
Most Asians I know may or may not be good at studying. However, I do know that their family tends to push them hard to study and to succeed. Such pressure can easily cause one to be motivated at studying. Indeed, I know in Japan that not only are test scores higher, but suicide rates as well. Shall we assume that Asians have suicide genes too?
So, in conclusion, before joining the Klan try learning a bit more about genetics.
"(A+Bn)/n = x, hence God exists, reply!"
[ Parent ]